| Seattle Magazine - Best Restaurant Award April 2009  |
 |
| Evening Magazine Best of Western Washington Best Pizza -- Single Local 1993 |
 |
| Zagat Rated 2008 - 2011 UWers and Husky alums have been packing this University District "legend" "since the beginning of time" to wolf down "heavy" Seattle Pizzas that are "the size of Mt. Rainier"; its "servers and bartenders are all great", and as for the "not fancy" decor, duh!, "it's a tavern", so "grab the baseball team" and hie [sic] here for a "pie and a pitcher". |
 |
| Best of City Search 2004-05 "Easily the best pizza in town." "Northlake is Seattle's premier abode for the hauntingly tasty delight!" "Excellent pizzeria and pub. Good beers and pizza to-die-for ... extremely thick and packed full of toppings." "None can maintain the quality of Northlake Tavern and Pizza House." "The pizza is seriously tasty. I like all pizza, and when I'm in the mood for a big, heart pizza with lots of fresh veggies and cheese, this is the one and only in Seattle." |
 |
| AOL City's Top Ten
"Even a 'small' tips the scale at well over two pounds. Try the ever-popular combo pizza (Italian beef sausage, pepperoni, with fresh mushrooms and black olives), the zesty chicken special or build your own from the wide array of toppings. If you're courageous enough to handle the huge pizza portions. |
 |